Fool’s Gold? Resident Files Suit Against Developers of LEED Gold Riverhouse For Not Delivering LEED Gold Goods

A new lawsuit calls into question whether Riverhouse, Battery Park City’s LEED Gold condo jewel, is actually delivering a gold-standard green living experience.

One thing that Battery Park City’s LEED Gold hopeful Riverhouse has never lacked for: publicity. Some of that media attention has been of the brand-friendly kind — Leonardo Di Caprio bought a condo! Tyra Banks bought a condo! These people are very famous! Or at least Leo is! But much of the recent attention directed at Riverhouse has not been very flattering. A series of legal squabbles between the developers – the Sheldrake Organization and the zombie iteration of the Lehman Brothers real estate partnership — were both notably ugly and notably public, although Riverhouse condos continued to sell well during the exchange of lawsuits and accusations and vague intimations of pre-foreclosure legal action.

A series of price cuts on the apartments probably helped, there, but in a certain, bottom-line sense, the steadiness of the sales amid all those PR bloopers is not really all that surprising. For one thing, everyone already knew that New York City real estate is (spoiler alert) populated by hugely litigious egomaniacs. For another, it’s not like the condos for sale at Riverhouse were diminished any in quality by the bickering money-men behind them. A LEED Gold imprimatur, David Rockwell interiors, a snappy design courtesy of Polshek Partnership, the usual luxury condo amenities: these are the things buyers wanted from a condo at Riverhouse, and it they had every reason to expect that all those things would be worth the money. And all the more reason to be angry if, say, Riverhouse’s vaunted air-filtration system didn’t work. Or if that ultra-efficient HVAC system didn’t actually keep the apartments warm in the winter. Or if the residences weren’t properly insulated. Or if several aspects of the design missed LEED Gold standards by 49%. Any of those things would be bad. All of them are alleged in a recent lawsuit filed against Riverhouse’s developers by a resident. Our own Stephen Del Percio broke this story over at Green Real Estate Law Journal, and the suit shows every indication of being a pretty big deal for one of New York City’s great green hopes.

The suit’s demand for $1.5 million in damages is kind of a grabber, but Stephen identified something more intriguing — and which could possibly make a bigger impact across the green building spectrum — than the intimation that one high-profile green building didn’t live up to its own hype. “This type of construction litigation is not uncommon, the purchasers also claim that ‘the building’s much-heralded ‘green’ heating system consistently fails to provide adequate heat’ to their unit and that this failure is a condition which is ‘is materially different from those represented by the project sponsor and its principals in the condominium offering plan,’” Stephen writes. “These allegations – which are the the basis for two claims in the complaint alleging fraud and misrepresentation – mark the first time we have seen claims asserted against the developer of a green building for the developer’s alleged failure to deliver the project as represented during pre-construction.” This is an important first, and could set a precedent that real estate developers aren’t likely to like. Allegations against one green building’s developers for not delivering the green goods are gossip; a legal precedent establishing that a green building’s developer can be sued for (alleged) fraud and misrepresentation for not delivering the green goods is something that could change the way green building gets done. The suit could also ding the reputation of the USGBC’s LEED, since it highlights LEED’s single most glaring flaw: its tendency to grade on the blueprints, rendering actual building performance something of an afterthought.

Stephen goes on to explain the legal ramifications of all this far better than I could — he is, after all, a lawyer; I am a moonlighting sports blogger with an insulation fetish — and it’s really worth clicking here and reading his whole post. And while it might be foolish to guess at the possible future impact (if any) on the green building business… well, there is a comments section for that, if you’re feeling it. This will obviously be a story worth watching, and Stephen and I will have more on it next week.

About David Roth

Since September of 2009, David Roth has served as the Managing Editor of gbNYC. David lives on the Upper East Side of Manhattan with his wife, and is also a freelance writer whose work has appeared in The New Republic and the Wall Street Journal, among other publications. You can contact David at droth11@gmail.com.

about gbNYC

gbNYC is a multi-disciplinary consulting and real estate services firm. In addition to representing office tenants and commercial buyers in leasing and acquisitions, we also provide innovative consulting solutions from a unique, green building perspective. We advise on green building financial incentives, comment on proposed green building marketing strategies, author white papers, treatises, and market analyses, organize seminars on the LEED process and professional accreditation, and provide advice and analysis on green building risk management and the overall state of green real estate, leasing, and construction, in New York City and beyond.

Our blog, the gbNYC+ journal of real estate, law, + sustainability, delivers consistent, original content - from a New York City perspective - on how technology, data, and sustainability are changing how we interact with our built environment. Subscribe below and receive new articles as they're published or connect with our social media presence to join our ongoing conversation about real estate and sustainability, in the Big Apple and beyond. Contact us at (201) 835-8530 or info@gbNYC.com for more information about our services and to discuss how we can assist you.

,

No comments yet.
gbNYC Tenant Resources Feature

tenant resources

The commercial office leasing process is complicated. And so is figuring out where to start your search for office space in New York City. gbNYC's tenant resources - from our blog and leasing FAQ to our unwavering dedication to our clients and commercial real estate - can help you get the best possible deal for your next office, in the best location, and at the best price.
gbNYC Submarket Feature

submarkets

New York City is a big place, and figuring out the most suitable location for your office can seem like an insurmountable challenge. Our submarket guide demystifies Gotham's dizzying range of neighborhoods with profiles, articles, new developments, and recent leasing statistics like average asking rents and vacancy rates.
gbNYC Database Feature

office database

We've built a database of the best commercial properties in New York City, focused on LEED-certified, Energy Star-labeled, and historic office buildings. Search for your ideal office building by location, certification, size, or owner. Then contact us to discuss current availabilities and your specific office needs.