Green Insurance Law: Industry Thoughts on BIM and LEED Coverage for Design Professionals

The standard of care for designers is “changing rapidly,” in large part due to the power of BIM technologies and the proliferation of systems like LEED.

Last week, the AIANYS Statewide Advisory Committee and the American Council of Engineering Companies of New York sponsored the 2007 Annual Joint Session on Current Insurance Issues for Design Professionals. Speakers from a number of prominent insurance companies, including Lexington, Beazley, Zurich, CNA, Liberty, and XL shared their thoughts on the current state of the insurance industry, from a softening market for professional liability insurance, to comments that several panelists made regarding the insurance coverage implications of BIM and LEED for design professionals. Of particular interest to us here at gbNYC, the entire panel agreed that the standard of care for architects and engineers is “changing rapidly,” in large part due to the power of BIM technologies and the proliferation of USGBC’s LEED green building rating system.

First, with respect to BIM (which is discussed extensively in the context of sustainable design in the latest issue of eco-structure magazine), each insurer confirmed that their professional liability policies would cover errors and omissions in digital data, including BIM models. However, Lexington’s representative called BIM “just 3-D CAD” and warned the audience that the true insurance coverage implications for BIM projects have yet to play out.

In an interesting, though potentially sinister, twist, Beazley’s panelist also noted that coverage would not extend in the type of situation where a firm hosted a BIM model on its own server, the server was compromised by some sort of hacker, and the digital model was damaged. This is not a designer’s error or omission, so coverage would not be available to the architect or engineer who built the model. The same panelist noted that hidden risks are “key” with respect to BIM, and designers should guide themselves on such projects accordingly.

In terms of green projects, each of the panelists agreed that a design professional’s errors and omissions coverage will not cover claims by an owner brought in the event that a LEED project does not reach the agreed-upon certification level. Guarantees are where architects and engineers will get into trouble; these types of policies only cover professional negligence and not a designer’s guarantee of a particular sustainable outcome. Obviously, the key here is retaining green-savvy counsel that understands the LEED system and certification process, can effectively communicate these types of concerns to the owner on the design professional’s behalf, and at the same time negotiate contract language that reflects an acceptable level of risk for the designer to accept in connection with the project. Check out gbNYC’s previous posts on this critical issue.

Still, Zurich’s panelist rather ominously observed that his firm has “never seen a standard of care shift so quickly with so much media coverage and political backing.” He also noted that adding fuel to the sea change are owners who are “being told that sustainable design will help save them money. Claims start with violated expectations.” Insurance against professional negligence protects design professionals against claims that they did not perform up to their standard of care, which is defined as the level of skill of similar professionals in a similar location.

For example, similar professionals could be deemed to be LEED Accredited Professionals, expected to design projects and building systems that perform at a higher level. The danger here is that all architects and engineers- whether they are competent in green design practices or not- will be held to that elevated standard of care. If their designs do not perform as intended, or do not incorporate sufficient sustainable measures, it is possible that litigation could ensue. While professional negligence insurance does follow the prevailing standard of care, the fact that the insurance industry is observing a rapid increase in that standard- driven in large part by sustainability- should be of concern to design professionals.

Undoubtedly we will see these issues play out in a number of ways- both in practice and in commentary- over the course of the next few months. The legal profession, in cooperation with the design, construction, and real estate industries, must continue to explore these issues in detail and analyze the implications of both BIM and green building certification regimes during the course of 2008 in order to effectively assist stakeholders in successfully managing the hidden risks of green construction.

About Stephen Del Percio

Stephen Del Percio has written for gbNYC+ since 2006 and currently serves as in-house counsel for one of the world's largest engineering, construction, and technical services companies. He earned a B.Eng. from Columbia, his J.D. at William & Mary, and lives in New York City with his wife and daughter. You can follow Stephen on Twitter, email him at stephen@gbNYC.com, or join gbNYC on Facebook to continue the conversation.

about gbNYC

gbNYC is a multi-disciplinary consulting and real estate services firm. In addition to representing office tenants and commercial buyers in leasing and acquisitions, we also provide innovative consulting solutions from a unique, green building perspective. We advise on green building financial incentives, comment on proposed green building marketing strategies, author white papers, treatises, and market analyses, organize seminars on the LEED process and professional accreditation, and provide advice and analysis on green building risk management and the overall state of green real estate, leasing, and construction, in New York City and beyond.

Our blog, the gbNYC+ journal of real estate, law, + sustainability, delivers consistent, original content - from a New York City perspective - on how technology, data, and sustainability are changing how we interact with our built environment. Subscribe below and receive new articles as they're published or connect with our social media presence to join our ongoing conversation about real estate and sustainability, in the Big Apple and beyond. Contact us at (201) 835-8530 or info@gbNYC.com for more information about our services and to discuss how we can assist you.

, , , , , , , , ,

No comments yet.
gbNYC Tenant Resources Feature

tenant resources

The commercial office leasing process is complicated. And so is figuring out where to start your search for office space in New York City. gbNYC's tenant resources - from our blog and leasing FAQ to our unwavering dedication to our clients and commercial real estate - can help you get the best possible deal for your next office, in the best location, and at the best price.
gbNYC Submarket Feature

submarkets

New York City is a big place, and figuring out the most suitable location for your office can seem like an insurmountable challenge. Our submarket guide demystifies Gotham's dizzying range of neighborhoods with profiles, articles, new developments, and recent leasing statistics like average asking rents and vacancy rates.
gbNYC Database Feature

office database

We've built a database of the best commercial properties in New York City, focused on LEED-certified, Energy Star-labeled, and historic office buildings. Search for your ideal office building by location, certification, size, or owner. Then contact us to discuss current availabilities and your specific office needs.